Posted:
10/02/02© 2002 Filmmonthly.com 24 Hour Party People
(2002)
|
Michael
Winterbottom, known for such films as Jude and an episode of the
dark, dreary television show Cracker, directed this light hearted
look at the Manchester music scene from 1976-early 90's. It is a far departure
for him and based on those movies alone I really would not have guessed
he was involved in 24 Hour Party People. When I started reading about
the film I realized he is also from Manchester. I have always loved when
people make movies about their own home towns because they have such a genuinely
honest feeling to them, maybe not always based in exact facts and sometimes
preposterous in nature but always with a sense of truth and genuine understanding.
Take, for example, John Waters and his lovingly charming look at Baltimore
with his film Pecker or writer Lona William's film Drop Dead Gorgeous,
an honest portrayal of a small town beauty pageant similar to one she won.
24 Hour Party People is the general
story of the Manchester music scene and specifically focusing on Factory
Records and Tony Wilson. Factory Records is the label responsible for
bringing to the world Joy Division, Happy Mondays and New Order. You will
notice I did not say they signed them, but rather brought them to us and
the reason for my particular wording is that Factory Records was not a
business. It was a group of people who recognized talent and went that
extra step to assure artistic freedom, by not dealing in contracts and
all the other traditional things record labels are known for. I use the
term "recognized talent" in the broadest sense, because I don't feel Tony
Wilson is a person who necessarily understands good business or great
talent, but rather is merely a very lucky man. He was in the right place
at the right time and knew what he liked. None of his ventures with various
bands or even the Hacienda, one of the most popular clubs in the world
made him a rich man. These things just got him a place in music history
and I'm not even sure he was doing it for that. He seemed to deal with
these bands and the insanity that followed them for some inexplicable
reason. The movie doesn't explain it, because I feel Tony Wilson, himself
can't explain his own reasons.
Steve Coogan, who is a well-known actor
from British television, plays the character of Tony Wilson. I had neither
seen nor heard of Steve Coogan before this movie but he seemed to be very
much in tune with the character and what was expected. One aspect I really enjoyed in the film,
which tends to be something that would normally keep me irritated throughout,
is the fact we didn't get to know the characters very well. We never really
understood many motives or their general characters and this is probably
an accurate portrayal of how they lived. These guys seemed more like party
friends, instead of real friends. They were the kind of people you meet
late in the bar and hang out with all night drinking and partying but
really know very little about their day-to-day lives. Many critics have said the movie was boring
because they couldn't "get" the characters because they lacked substance.
From JoBlo's Movie Emporium, "For me, the film went on for too long,
delivered very little substance, offered zero interesting characters with
no depth and ultimately just bored the crap out of me. Oh by the way,
some of the stuff depicted in this movie didn't actually happen either
so don't go believing everything you see in there either. So what's the
fuckin' point?! Like I said...I guess I just didn't "get" it." Well, the "fucking point" is that it is
rock and roll, which if done correctly also lacks substance, offers little
depth and isn't always the truth, so a film about rock and roll should
offer the same. I thought 24 Hour Party People never tried to be
more than one person's snapshot of a fun time in Manchester history. The
film makes fun of itself continuously throughout which is another quality
I find endearing.
Laura Abraham is a freelance living in Ann Arbor, Michigan, which is about 20 minutes outside Detroit. |